23 Million Dollars Stolen On Maui

December 25, 2010
By

White Collar Crime Is Hawaii’s Dirty Little Secret.

Kimura Busted In 20 Year Multimillion Dollar Ponzi Scheme On Maui.

Grow or sell pot and you are called a danger and may even get no bail – look at Roger Christie. But steal 23 million dollars over 20 years and you are free to roam the community and to use those ill gotten gains for your defense.

Hawaii county prosecutor Jay Kimura’s brother,  Lloyd Kimura has been charged criminally for running a multimillion dollar ponzi scheme on Maui that began 1985.

While Jay was prosecuting medical marijuana patients and over 400 people last year alone for under 1 ounce of marijuana, his brother was stealing millions from Hawaii county residents. Jay put 63 year old David Finely in prison for 20 years and 23 year old Sequoia Heuer in prison for 10 years for marijuana. How many years do you think his brother should get for stealing 23 million dollars? Will he even see a day in jail? He hasn’t yet.

This case raises some other serious questions:  Was any of the money used for political campaigns? Has it bought influence? The corrupt culture and white collar crime in Hawaii — including the Hawaii county police department and  prosecutor’s office — over the years should concern us all. The police cheating scandal, the Mathison murder case, the missing $50,000.00 dollars from police evidence lockers, the Kamaaina  Pumping scandal, bulldozer gate and Pohakuloa tack coat are just a few of the more well know incidents of corrupt culture in Hawaii county. In all that, only Mathison went to jail, the police had exonerated him, but the community rebelled and only after months of community pressure and protest did the Mathison murder get prosecuted. Jay Kimura has said he will not prosecute a police officer. And he doesn’t —  he also does not go after white collar crime in the county of Hawaii. That has led to a culture of lawlessness, and as a result many crimes go unpunished, but marijuana crimes get massive resources and a high priority.

Maui businessman Lloyd Kimura was charged with two counts of prohibited securities practice and two counts of making false or misleading financial statements, by the State of Hawaii Attorney general. Filed in 2nd Circuit Court on Monday. The complaint was announced Thursday evening.  The criminal charges come on the heals of civil suits filed earlier this year. Kimura’s criminal attorney, Phil Lowenthal, has been talking with prosecutors for some time. Kimura was able to avoid the normal grand jury indictments that many marijuana defendants face as a result of a deal he cut with prosecutors from the state.

Kimura, president of Maui Industrial Loan & Finance Co., ran a certified public accounting firm, Lloyd Y. Kimura Inc., on Maui for many years, he is 61 years old.

The criminal complaint charges that from June 30, 2008, to June 30, 2009, Kimura filed false or misleading statements and failed to provide other statements required by law on behalf of Maui Industrial Loan. The documents in question were filed with the Financial Institutions Division of the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs.

According to the complaint  Lloyd Kimura initiated a scheme to defraud people in amounts greater than $100,000, between February 2007 and June 2009 using offers to purchase and sell various securities.

In November, the state Division of Financial Institutions ordered Maui Industrial/ Maui Finance ( MILFCO) to stop taking deposits and the business imploded. Mr. Kimura has owned and managed Maui Finance for decades. Kimura, acknowledged during depositions earlier this year that he had used money from late investors to pay off early investors, without really generating income from operations.

In civil court the trustee in the Maui Industrial Finance Co. bankruptcy case, Dane Field, has sued 25 investors to recover money they received as interest on their original investment or deposit, Field contends the money was not really interest but the fruits of a Ponzi scheme.

The scam used a loan company also known as Maui Finance, that did little or no legitimate business. Mr Kimura would take money from new investors (or depositors) and use it to pay interest or dividends to previous investors (or depositors). Much like the infamous ponzi scheme Bernie Madoff ran, also for years. It will be interesting to see if Mr. Kimura actually goes to prison. Where are the feds in this case? With Jay Kimura’s connections to prosecutors and law enforcement around the state will his brother get special treatment? With the massive amount of money involved will Kimura buy his freedom? Roger Christie is in jail with no bail all his assets seized while Kimura is free and is using stolen money to mount a defense. Justice in Hawaii seems to be for sale based on who you know IMO. The feds should take over this case to remove the appearance of or actual subversion of justice.

Most of the money Kimura stole was in cash from people that trusted him, in one incident, he took $2 million from one person. In depositions, Kimura is purported to have admitted he had been operating a Ponzi scheme almost from the day he became sole owner of the company around 1985. As the only officer and director he  made all the decisions. Other than Mr. Kimura Maui Finance had just one employee, an office manager.

The liabilities total nearly $23 million in the two separate bankruptcy filings and are very similar. It is still unclear how much money Maui Finance took in over the years. Some investors thought they were depositors in a bank, others may have known they were speculative lenders. One RNI invested $1 million, and received stock, totaling 40 percent ownership of Maui Financial. It appears this was a fraud also as 100 percent of the firm’s stock appears to have already have  been used to secure a bank loan.

The facts appear to indicate Maui Finance wasn’t making loans. Its payouts of interest were really distributions of new capital from new investors or depositors, in a classic ponzi scheme. It looks like premeditated theft from anyone Kimura could get to trust him. For me this raises questions about his brother Jay’s access to the asset seizure funds under his control in Hawaii county, That fund has little if any over site and has never been audited. It too runs in the millions too the order of roughly 3 million dollars per year according to the Hawaii county prosecutors budget. Jay Kimura is prosecuting legal medical patients and refusing to obey the voter passed law on marijuana in Hawaii county. It really looks like  prosecutions are prioritized by how much money they add to his budget even at the expense of existing laws.  In light of everything we know now the legislative auditor needs to immediately audit the Hawaii county prosecutors office in my opinion. Contempt for our laws by the Hawaii county prosecutor and the culture of looking the other way when it comes to white collar crime by his department demand an audit. With millions of dollars basically in a slush fund with no oversite the temptation may be to great particularly when its clear he uses laws to suit his personal agenda, part of which seems to center around getting more money into the asset fund.

The way Ponzi scheme’s work, depositors who get in early get paid more money than they put in, but investors who came in late end up getting little or nothing. The way asset funds work they could be used for political or personal gain at the prosecutors discretion.

Kimura falsely claimed he could pay between 8 percent and 15 percent, but typically 12 percent, while certificates of deposit where paying only 1 percent or 2 percent. Kimura told potential investors he was re-lending the money at very high rates of interest. That appears to be a complete fabrication.

Things began to unravel when one of the big investors, the one who put up $1 million dollars to buy a 40 percent interest in Maui Financial in 1999, wanted to sell its interest back to Kimura. After seven years, the Iwamoto (Roberts Hawaii) family, (RNI) demanded $2.5 million.

That was the principal with the interest they would have earned at 12 percent. Kimura agreed to buy them out, and made payments of around $1 million, but failed to pay the remaining $1.5 million. RNI sued and was awarded nearly $2 million. That was the end of the scam he had successfully run for so many years.

When the state issued its order against taking deposits it set off a run on the bank as investors scrambled to try and get their money back. Some depositors had left their money with Kimura for many years and never taken any out  while some of the lucky ones had been paid with other peoples money.

At  his deposition Kimura was ask: “And is it your testimony that you also made payments to the investors from money you borrowed from other four investors?” Kimura replied: “Yes, and myself. I would put money in from my various companies. If the – if the need – the need for funds was there I would put money in.” Kimura went on to say he did this from the start.

The state attorney general and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, had been investigating this for some time before charges were brought, however Mr.Kimura was free and likely moved assets around or hid them. That is the opposite of what we see in the marijuana cases were assets are seized right away, including many times family homes that have been owned for years, cars money and anything else of value.

Arraignment, is scheduled at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday before Circuit Judge Joseph Cardoza. Prohibited securities practice is a class A felony with a maximum penalty of 20 years or a fine of $50,000 or both. Making false financial statements is a class C felony with a maximum penalty of five years or a fine of $20,000 or both.

Mr. Kimura’s problems and victims don’t end there.  Other law suits are pending against Kimura by people who took promissory notes, with claims ranging from $1 million to more than $2 million. What passes for justice in Hawaii is outrageous. Americans accused of marijuana crimes that generally are between consenting parties and rarely if ever have victims are held without bail as dangerous and have their assets seized. While crimes like Mr. Kimura committed, where there are clear and identified victims he is allowed to use his assets and remain free. Mr. Kimura did far more harm to the people of Hawaii than Roger Christie ever did. Yet he is given every chance to defend himself and allowed to hide and convert assets and use those assets to defend himself. Roger is a political prisoner that is obvious, he is a minnow when compared to the criminal Kimura. Free Roger Christie and give his cell to Lloyd Kimura. That would be justice, to do any less is just another scam.

I believe the legislative auditor needs to audit the Hawaii county prosecutors office immediately.

_________________

Ref:


Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

| Print This Post Print This Post
  • Matt Rifkin

    hey…Kimura-san made the local TV news too…

    http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/Global/story.asp?S=13791797

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

    • Thomas

      The guy steals 20 million or more and gets barely a mention, while a guy gets busted for growing marijuana and you have mug shots and a huge story.

      What is wrong with the mainstream media? They didn’t even mention his brother is the Hawaii county prosecutor and is prosecuting even legal medical patients. They also didn’t mention he went gambling 4 times a year. There is so much more to this story than some guy growing pot. The media is manipulating public opinion as if we didn’t know that already. The way this was handled is a glaring example of that. Loyd Kimura did far more harm than Roger Christie but gets a pass from the media. Something stinks here……

      See Matt’s link for the story…….

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0

  • http://hawaiinewsdaily go lakers

    from Curtis Narimatsu, whose short post at sister blog Hawaii Net Daily is published here to supplement pseudonym Thomas’ extraordinary article –

    Ponzi scheme prison sentences

    Ron Rewald got over 80 yrs. federal prison sentence, or nearly 5 times longer than our local court metes out vs. a defendant like prosecutor Jay Kimura’s brother Lloyd. Rewald bilked investors of $22 million, which in today’s numbers exceed Kimura’s alleged take by 3. Nationallly, Bernie Madoff got 150 yrs. in federal prison.

    Being the baby brother, it’s likely that Jay 1) looks away from white collar crime; 2) won’t prosecute egregious instances of corruption allegedly like Kamaaina Pumping’s plunder of County coffers, nor will Jay refer such matters to our State Attorney General’s office.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 1

    • Jan

      You got it Dwight…right on the money….resolving this continued preferential treatment of the “in crowd” is a hill that is never ending to reach to the top…

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • Dwight Kondo

    Will Lloyd Kimura’s wife, Jeannie, come out smelling better than”¦
    BERNIE MADOFF’S WIFE, RUTH DID?

    Looks as if Lloyd knew “Ëœhow to work the law’ with, no doubt, some good, free and timely FAMILY advice.

    If Kimura can hide his loot better than that Old White Shark Bernie, and even make a deal and get off real easy, we’d have a world class shyster of our very own! Maui no ka oe, as those tourist like to say!

    FROM: PACIFIC BUSINESS NEWS,
    Maui businessman owes $23.8M following 2 bankruptcies
    “¦
    “Because his wife, Jennie Kimura, did not file for bankruptcy, the properties are”¨ not part of the bankruptcy estate because they are owned by the Kimuras as “¨tenants by the entirety, Wagner said. “Everything that he has that’s in his estate will be liquidated,”
    Wagner said. “In order to keep [the nine properties] he still has to pay the mortgages on them or else they’re subject to foreclosure.”
    The loan company has about $4 million in receivables, but $3 million was from Kimura, who apparently borrowed the money from the (his own) loan company, Wagner said. The remainder is loans issued to customers, whose payments are now being collected by the trustee.
    Kimura, who also is a certified public accountant, listed $4.25 million in “¨assets, the bulk of that in real estate. He owns 10 properties, but is claiming exemption for nine of them, including his home and the office building, because they are jointly owned with his wife.”

    As far as we know, Bernie wasn’t THAT cool to Ruthie.

    See? Local Shysters are more considerate than Painland counterparts.

    Right!

    http://tinyurl.com/34eldlb

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • http://hawaiinewsdaily go lakers

    Thanks for the call and info last night, Thomas.

    Great article and good analysis.

    Why is the County spending so much money on marijuana eradication when the prices of pakalolo are the lowest in twenty years. The policy has not helped in keeping marijuana off the streets and marijuana does not harm anyone, anyway.

    But Kamaina Pumping Service allegedly cost the County of Hawaii TAXPAYERS $6,ooo,ooo million dollars in over billing during a 13 year period from 1996 to 2009. This was an alleged rigged and closed to competition procurement contract bid (it should have been opened to all contractors doing curb gutter and dry well maintenance) that should have been investigated by the Chief Prosecutor years ago.

    The trail of alleged graft and corruption in the awarding of Kamaina Pumping Service this closed contract with the county and the dropping of the bid price (by half) when it was exposed by a West Hawaii Today artice in 2009 and opened to the public after 13 years is obvious and an insult to everyone’s intelligence. The price of services for Kaimana’s work was set at 110k a month in 1996 and the price of services to the tax payer is now 50k a month less thru competition after the exposure and pulling of the county contract in 2009 because of the media coverage is pretty blatantly obvious.

    How can Kaimana drop it’s services fees by 50k a month, they bided and won the county contract by bidding at over a 100k in 1996, after 13 years of rising expenses due to costs of doing business.

    I would expect the local prosecutors office to go after this type of alleged white collar crime, my understanding is the prosecutors office will not even look in to these allegations, when this alleged rigged procurement contract is doing more harm to the community than marijuana ever could.

    The Chief Prosecutor is not looking in to this case with Kaimana, like the office refuses to investigate white collar or public corruption crimes here on the island, while his brother in Maui destroyed the lives of many individuals, families and business by using his alleged knowledge of his clients finances as their CPA to prey on them and swindle over 20 million dollars of their hard earned money.

    In any other state in the country, Kaimana and Lloyd Kimura would be thoroughly investigated, the local governments would take the stance these type of actions would not be tolerated and all parties would be facing SERIOUS federal law enforcement accountability if not acted on swiftly by the local jurisdictions.

    Did Lloyd donate to his brother’s political campaigns with any of the funds stolen in this alleged Ponzi scheme? Again, if a politican was caught receiving campaign donations from a source alleged to be in comparison to this instance…heads would roll.

    Where and what is our Chief Prosecutors position on this?

    Is the going to just hope it goes away and make no comment because he does not feel we are entitled to one?

    Probably so… that is why we need change.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 1

  • Dwight Kondo

    Hawaii Better Business Bureau

    GAVE AN A+ RATING TO LLLOYD KIMURA’S BUSINESS, milf co!!

    sounds about right if you don’t care about better businesses

    http://tinyurl.com/25oextd

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • Dwight Kondo

    NOW DIG THIS!!! $CAMMING PEOPLE$’ MILLION$ I$ $TRE$$FUL!!

    FROM PACIFIC BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 18, 2004

    “Employers and employees try to cope with workplace stress”

    Accountant Lloyd Kimura lives and works on the honeymoon island of Maui.
    Yet when it comes to shedding months of pent-up job stress, relief is thousands of miles away.
    As many as four times a year, the Hawaii native trades his office chair for a seat inside the Indian casinos dotting the California desert.
    “A week max,” Kimura says of his trips to the mainland. “It forces my mind to focus on something other than work.”
    Kimura’s time out for self-indulgence is one example of how millions of Americans are learning to deal with on-the-job stress.

    “I AM SURE MY CLIENTS THINK I DESERVE IT!” (made that up)

    Read more: Employers and employees try to cope with workplace stress | Pacific Business News

    http://tinyurl.com/2ak2acv

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  • Dwight Kondo

    And the news from The Honolulu Staradvertiser Dec 25, 2010 In regards to this? HPD car chase got more print. No mention of the millions!

    Story is on back page under “Police & Fire”. Business as usual!!

    NEIGHBOR ISLANDS

    Maui man is charged in Ponzi plot
    State prosecutors have charged a Maui businessman accused of running a Ponzi scheme with two counts of making false or misleading financial statements and two counts of prohibited securities practices.

    The state attorney general’s office said Thursday that Maui Industrial Loan & Finance Co. President Lloyd Kimura filed false or misleading statements in company documents.

    It also alleges he defrauded two couples of at least than $100,000.

    Maui Industrial has filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Kimura has filed for personal bankruptcy.

    Kimura could not immediately be reached for comment.

    http://tinyurl.com/2bvyspl

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • Dwight Kondo

    What is shameful is the fact that the Feds will spend all that money to investigate, detain and now prosecute Roger Christie all the while not a peep about THE REAL CRIME in Hawaii Nei. When was the last time the Feds seriously prosecuted a Hawaii politician or official? ALA’s!!

    I cannot help but think that due to the illegitimate State of Hi and statehood itself, a Federal hands-off policy in regards to Hawaii government crime, is a fact.

    So as one dirty hand washes the other dirty hand, we get the pilau laundry.

    dirty laundry and dirty and corrupt local government…

    TIME TO OVERGROW!

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • Hokulani Cheneviere

    “Roger Christie being held with bail”
    I meant held WITHOUT Bail. Yes, not only that DENIED 5 times. What kind of JUSTICE is this? THESE ASSHOLES WILL get their Karmic due one day. How do they sleep at night? I bet they are friggin Pill addicts. Gotta be.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • Hokulani Cheneviere

    I have had a HUGE suspicion that Jay Kimura is instrumental in Roger Christie being held without bail. Gotta be, because nothing else makes sense. Besides that Jay Kimura has a huge motive for revenge since Roger sued for expenses in the hemp seed case from the early nineties. Jay never got over that, since Roger and his partner won and received $75K! This is just pure EVIL! Mahalo for exposing this steaming dogturd of corruption.

    Well-loved. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 4 Thumb down 0

  • Mackenzie

    Wish someone on the inside would leak info about Jay’s possible ongoing knowledge of his brothers crime, or at least reveal some commentary made in private. Pillars in the community. We could use a
    “localleaks.com”
    Nice Thomas.
    Mayapple, whose years of tireless diligence put Mathison behind bars, may have sacrificed her health in the process. Remember Mayapple.

    Well-loved. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 7 Thumb down 0

    • Thomas

      Peter

      We all owe Mayapple a great debt and can learn a lot from what she accomplished, we should never forget that………Aloha

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0

      • buddah belly

        Yes, Friends for Justice is kind of a spin-off on Mayapple’s Citizen’s for Justice, she was one strong, courageous woman…

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0

    • Dwight Kondo

      Shame for the Kimura Family!!!

      but then, maybe not, huh?

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  • buddah belly

    I wonder if Lloyd took his brother Jay to Las Vegas and Reno gambling on stolen money???

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  • Dwight Kondo

    WHEN THE GOVERNMENT BREAKS THE LAW, THERE IS NO LAW!

    …and they been breaking it for years and see what we get?

    Thomas!!! Terrific story and reporting!

    Word is, Lloyd was a high roller in Lost Wages and Reno-where-it-all-went.

    Lloyd Kimura, brother of Hawaii County Prosecutor Jay Kimura, knew how to play this ponzi game. I googled this since your article from Maui News:” …some of the 25 people being sued may have been legitimate borrowers, not depositors, but the trustee had to sue all of them to protect the estate’s interests because the statute of limitations term expired Tuesday. Records are incomplete and confusing, and payouts that look to Field like returns to depositors in some cases may have been real loans.

    AND SMALL KINE POLITICS, AT LEAST THE ONES DECLARED:

    Lloyd Y Kimura from zip code 96793
    Political contributions disclosed by campaign committees to the Federal Election Commission, sorted by name, zip code and employer. The data, from the FEC, covers the years 1979 through 2008.

    Candidates
    Lloyd Y Kimura

    $400 to Daniel Akaka, Daniel K Akaka For U S Senate on November 25, 1991

    Lloyd Y Kimura, Cpa, Lloyd Y. Kimura Cpa Inc.

    $250 to Mazie Hirono, Friends Of Mazie Hirono on March 30, 2006

    Committees
    Lloyd Y Kimura

    $400 to Daniel K Akaka For U S Senate on November 25, 1991

    Lloyd Y Kimura, Cpa, Lloyd Y. Kimura Cpa Inc.

    $250 to Friends Of Mazie Hirono on March 30, 2006

    Lloyd Y Kimura, 96793 (watchdog.net)

    THOMAS! We ALL owe you ONE BEEG MAHALO!!!

    M A H A L O !!

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

Featured

Ashida’s Conflict of Interest

What has been unstated in the media until now is that Lincoln Ashida's campaign spending report shows that he accepted a $200 campaign contribution...
Read more »

Hawaiian Sovereignty: Clarifying the Record

This letter is in response to Dr. Ken Conklin’s article  printed in the Hawai`i Reporter online on September 1, 2011, as well as the...
Read more »

Ashida Plays Politics with County Council

By Curtis Narimatsu and Go Lakers Mayor Billy Kenoi’s veto of the County of Hawaii budget for 2011-2012 was made possible by Corporation Counsel Lincoln Ashida’s handy declaration...
Read more »

Mayor Kenoi’s “Public Relations” Staff Quiet on Kama’aina Pumping Scandal

A public/media relations professional is the opposite of a journalist, in that a public relations crisis entails damage control, not damage proliferation. And a...
Read more »

The Kama’aina Pumping Scandal Remains Scandalous

By Curtis Narimatsu and Pseudonym Golakers Kama’aina Pumping Service, owned by County of Hawaii Public Works Automotive Division Head, Randy Riley, was chosen by the...
Read more »

Switch to our mobile site